Compilation of the effective indicators of the smart city in the intermediate development of the 8th district of Tabriz

Document Type : Research Paper


1 Department of Geography and Urban Planning, Tabriz Branch, Islamic Azad university, Tabriz, Iran

2 Department of Green Space Engineering, Tabriz University, Tabriz, Iran


In recent years, the excessive spatial expansion of cities, along with the unplanned development plans, especially in big cities like Tabriz, has caused the creation of new urban textures and as a result, relocated residents and uses to new areas. As a result, the historical and old contexts of these cities have changed their function and have tended to the worn-out urban regions and the loss of urban life, stagnation and exhaustion. For this purpose, first, by studying the available documents, all the factors involved in the smart development and the integration of the worn-out urban fabric were studied, and by using the Delphi method, 53 variables were extracted in the mentioned basin. For data analysis, the interaction/structural effects analysis method was used by FL Micmac software. Also, Scenario Wizard software was used to develop scenarios. The results of the research show the instability of the system in the metropolis of Tabriz, based on which, five categories of influential, two-faceted, influential, independent and identifiable risk factors are identified, after identifying 14 key factors through risk and influencing variables, as a result, 8 final key components were selected. And these factors were entered into the Scenario Wizard software, and based on the opinions of experts, re-weighting and 6 very strong scenarios were selected from 260 possible scenarios. Based on the results obtained, expanding local access by strengthening physical and digital networks in the region, creating a mechanism to use the enormous potentials of social strata in the context, interdepartmental coordination between responsible institutions in line with sustainable development, comprehensive and principled planning to follow user principles Lands and per capita compliance, etc., were selected as the most optimal and desirable possible scenarios.
Extended Abstract
Today, cities operate not as a hierarchy but as a network. Meanwhile, technological advances and other factors have accelerated the population changes, increasing the population of cities and upsetting social and environmental balances. The smart city refers to smart solutions that allow modern cities to improve their production quantitatively and qualitatively. One of the essential development plans of worn-out textures is the idea of infill development and is considered as one of the categories of smart urban growth, which, if used correctly, will develop old and worn-out areas of cities. The idea of ​​infill development is a subset of smart growth and sustainable urban development and has been proposed as a solution to improve the functional-spatial context of urban textures and mainly in traditional and historical textures, to fill the gaps in society and this development plays a vital role in harnessing existing urban potential. Also, endogenous development around the city is used to reduce the pressure of scattered development to lands. The present study aims to identify the most critical determinants and influential factors in the expansion of Tabriz Region 8.
The type of research is applied and is descriptive-analytical and survey in nature. Researchers first studied the indicators of smart urban development, in which the smart city includes six dimensions (smart people, smart life, smart environment, smart mobility, smart economy, smart governance) in general. Based on experts' opinions, 34 smart city sub-indicators were selected, which were used in the analysis. Also, 19 sub-indicators (based on authors 'studies and indexing with experts' opinions) were identified concerning infill development. After determining the key factors, different possible situations were considered for each key factor. And in the form of another questionnaire and based on the logic of the wizard scenario, it was weighted by experts (the weighting of this questionnaire is measured by pairwise
comparison and the relationship between variables in the range of numbers from 3 to -3). Professors also did the validity of this questionnaire in an interview, and through the Ensemble feature in the script wizard software, the questionnaires were entered in the wizard software.
Results and discussion
In this study, researchers prepared a questionnaire to determine the weights of criteria, and 50 relevant experts in the university and the municipality of Tabriz were surveyed. Fifty-three criteria were identified in the table related to the two main factors of smart development and infill development. Then, by placing these factors in a matrix of 53 by 53, these factors' effect on each other was determined by weighting the factors (from zero to 3).
Influential variables (because they are the most significant factors) and risk variables (due to their high capacity to become key factors of the system) were used, which are 14 factors. These factors include local access, access to public transportation, entrepreneurship, social cohesion, political views and strategies, urban per capita, participation in public life, productivity, creativity, cultural facilities, flexibility, sustainable and safe transportation, sustainable resource management, and population density. After consulting with experts, some of these factors were removed from the scripting process due to the close semantic relationship and others due to the semantic load disproportionate to infill development, and finally, eight factors remained.
Based on the results obtained from the Wizard scenario analysis, eight key components were selected for scenario development for the infill development in Tabriz Region 8, emphasizing the smart city. And for each of them, three possible scenarios were considered, for which a total of 24 possible scenarios were predicted. Possible situations include a range of desirable, undesirable, and critical conditions. Accordingly, eight variables (key variables identified by experts) were used.
This study aimed to develop compatible scenarios for the regional development of Tabriz. Based on this, ten general indicators (economic, security, settlements, relations, scientific development, production, natural, social, facilities, and regional conditions) were selected in the form of 53 sub-indicators in Tabriz Region 8. And 30 experts in the field of urban planning were considered research specialists, and a questionnaire in Excel was designed and sent to them. The final eight factors were considered based on the opinions of experts to develop scenarios, including local access, social cohesion and participation, political views and strategies, urban per capita, productivity, cultural facilities, sustainable resource management, population density. Finally, the most vital available scenarios, including six ones, were identified by appropriate experts to predict the system's future. Based on this, a desirable scenario, a critical scenario, and four combined neutral and critical scenarios were selected to develop Tabriz Region 8. Also, according to the System-Grid test, urban per capita (D) has the highest total factor (impact), and sustainable resource management variable (G) has the highest passive factor (impact). Also, the option of social cohesion and participation (B) obtained the lowest total sum, and the density component (H) had the lowest passive sum, according to experts. According to the obtained result, the first scenario is the best scenario imagined for region 8 in the direction of smart development. According to the obtained result, the first scenario is the best scenario imagined for region 8 in
the direction of smart development. Accordingly, the expansion of local access based on the strengthening of physical and digital networks in the region, the establishment of a mechanism to use the enormous potential of existing social groups in the texture, inter-sectoral coordination between responsible agencies for sustainable development, comprehensive and principled planning to follow the principles of land use and per capita, usage the great potential of the smart city for successful planning of the development of Tabriz, proper planning and attention to the historical and cultural texture of Tabriz Region 8, a compilation of a comprehensive plan for sustainable urban development to optimize the use of resources and in terms of land-use standards in the infill development of the region due to population density, were considered as the most optimal and desirable cases.
There is no funding support.
Authors’ Contribution
All of the authors approved thecontent of the manuscript and agreed on all aspects of the work.
Conflict of Interest
Authors declared no conflict of interest.
We are grateful to all the scientific consultants of this paper.


  1. Abedini, Asghar & Khalili, Amin. (2019) Determining the capacity infill development in growing metropolitans: A case study of Urmia city, Journal of Urban Management,Vol. 8, Issue. 2, pp. 316- 327.
  2. Blackman,Tim. (1995).Urban Policy in Practice, Publisher Taylor& Farancis Grop,December.
  3. Camporese, Rina & Di Prinzio, Luigi & Picchio, Stefano & Borga, Giovanni & Iandelli, Niccolo & Ragnoli, Antonella. (2011).New Technologies And EoSensor Data Build Up Knowledge For A Smart City, international Conference "Data Flow Form Space To Earth Application And Inter Operability ",Venice, Italy, 21-23 March.
  4. Caragliu, Andrea& Del Bo,Chiara& Nijkamp, Peter. (2009) Smart Cities in Europe, Journal of Urban Technology,Vol.18, Issue. 2, pp. 65- 82.
  5. Carrigg, Dan. (2012) Challenges to infill Development. Legislative director, California.Chicago Metropolitan Agency for Planning,Urban Design Strategy Report. Chicago, May.
  6. Caves, Roger.W (2005) Encyclopedia of the City,Pablisher routledge.
  7. Chiroma, Muhammad Ali & Harir Isa, Adamu & Gana, Bukar Abba & Bogoro, Audu Gani (2017), A review of infill development strategies in Nigeria, Journal of Applied Sciences in Environmental Sanitation, 3(8) (2017) 99-22
  8. Dadashpour, Hashem; Taqvaee, Ali Akbar; Ghaneh, Narges (2014) A Study of Infill Development Capacity in Urban Endowment Spaces: A Case Study: District 3, District 2, Yazd, Journal of Islamic Iranian City Studies, Spring, Volume, No. 15, pp. 78-63.
  9. Farhadi Mahalli, Ali (2011), An analytical study of the phenomenon of globalization with a focus on culture. Quarterly Journal of Strategic Studies in Public Policy, Winter, 5 consecutive, p. 63-96.
  10. farris, J.Terrence (2001)”Barriers to using urban infill development to achieve smart growth, Journal of Housing Policy Debate, Vol.12, pp.1-30.
  11. Gardiner,Gloria (2001) Commercial and mixed-use Handbook.Pablisher Oregon Transportation and Growth. Management(TGN Program staff).
  12. Gibson, Micheal & Kocabas, Arzu(2001) " London: Sustainable Regeneration-Challenge and Response ".Jornal of Rendez-vous Istanbul, vol.1, Mimar Sinan University, Istanbul,Turkey.
  13. Giffinger, Rudolf & Fertner, Christian& Kramar, Hans & Kalasek Robert. (2007) Smart cities: Ranking of European medium-sized cities, Publisher: Vienna University of Technology.
  14. Habibi, Kiomars; Poor Ahmad, Ahmad; Meshkini, Abolfazl (2007) Improvement and Renovation of Ancient Urban Textures, First Edition, Sanandaj: Kurdistan University Press.
  15. Hemphill Lesley & Berry, Jim &McGreal, Stanley (2004)An Indicator Based Approach to Measuring Sustainable Urban Regeneration Performance: Part2, Empirical Evaluation and Case Study AnalysisUrban Studies, Journal of Urban Studies, April, Vol. 41, Issue.4, pp. 757-772.
  16. Karimi, take it; Continuous, Jacob; Taghvaei, Massoud (2015) Explain and present the optimal model for allocating infill development capacities using GIS (Case study: Shiraz metropolis), Journal of New Attitudes in Human Geography, Spring, 10th year, No. 2, consecutive 38, p. 217-230.
  17. Khalili, Amin (2016) Presenting an optimal model for smart urban growth with emphasis on infill development (Case study: Urmia), Master Thesis in Urban Planning, under the guidance of Asghar Abedini, Faculty of Architecture, Urban Planning and Art, Urmia University.
  18. Khamachi, Behrooz (2005), Cultural and historical sites and celebrities of District 8 of Tabriz Municipality, first edition, Sotoudeh Publications.
  19. Kienitz, Roy (2001), Models and Guidelines for Infill Development, Publisher Maryland Department of Planning, October.
  20. Korczak, Jerzy & Kijewska, Kinga (2019) Smart logistics in the development of smart cities, Journal of Transportation Research Procedia, Vol.39, pp. 201-211.
  21. Kulpa Erica & Zamorano, Luis (2015) How Infill Development Can Help Stop Urban Sprawl, Publisher Urban Development, September
  22. Ligmann,Arika& Church,Richard& Jankowski, piotr (2005) Sustainable Urban Land Use Allocation with Spatial Optimization, Publisher Academia Accelerating the Worlds Research, http://www.geocomputation
  23. Litman, Todd(2021) Smart Growth Reforms, Pablisher Victoria Transport Policy Institute.
  24. Liu, Li.& Chen, Weiping& Nie, Min.& Zhang, Fengjuan& Wang, Yu.& He, Ailing. & Wang, Xiaonan& Yan, Gen (2016) iMAGE cloud: medical image processing as a service for regional healthcare in a hybrid cloud environment,Journal of Environmental health and preventive medicine, November,Vol.21,pp. 563-571.
  25. Loo B.P.Y, Becky& Cheng A.H.T,Amy & Nocholas.L, Samanhta (2017) Transit-oriented development on grrenfield versus infill sites: Some lessons from Hong Kong,Journal of Landscape and Urban Planning, Vol. 167, pp. 37-48.
  26. Mahesa, Restu& Yudoko, Gatot& Anggoro, Yudo (2019) Dataset on the sustainable smart city development in Indonesia, Journal of Data in brief,August, Vol. 25,, Article 104098.
  27. McConnell, Virginia& Wiley Keith. (2010) Infill Development: Perspectives and Evidence from Economics and Planning,Publisher Discussion paper, JEL Classification N. R11, R12, R14, May.
  28. Meijer, Albert & Bolívar, Manual. Pedro. Rodriguez (2016). Governing the smart city: a review of the literature on smart urban governance. International Review of Administrative Sciences,April, Vol.82,Issue.2,pp. 392-408.
  29. Merlin, Louis.A (2018) The influence of infill development on travel behavior,Journal of Research in Transportation Economies, May, Vol. 67,pp. 54-67.
  30. Mir Moghtadai, Mehta; Rafieian, Mojtaba; Sangi, Elham (2010), Reflections on the concept of infill development and its necessity in urban areas, Municipalities Monthly, Volume 10, Number 98, pp. 45-51.
  31. Mohammadzadeh, Rahmat (2006) The role of urban planning in reducing the effects of earthquakes, the first international conference on land hazards, natural disasters and coping strategies, University of Tabriz.
  32. Naghsheh Jahan Pars, Consulting Engineers (2007) Detailed plan of Tabriz historical-cultural region, East Azerbaijan Housing and Urban Development Organization.
  33. Nastaran, Homeland; Ghodsi, Narges (2015) Identification of areas prone to infill development in dysfunctional areas of cities (Case study: Isfahan Region 1), Journal of Urban Research and Planning, Spring, Volume 6, Number 20, pp. 51-68.
  34. Nemati Kottaei, Venus; Server, Rahim; Asadian, Farideh (1396) Stimulator of urban development; Concepts and Requirements, Scientific-Research Quarterly and International Quarterly of the Geographical Society of Iran, Winter, New Volume, Fifteenth Year, No. 55, pp.321-336.
  35. Ng,Mee.Kam (2005) Quality of life perceptions and directions for urban regeneration in Hong Kong,Journal of Social Indicator Research,Vol.71,pp.441-465.
  36. Ooi Joseph.T.L & Le T.T.Thao (2013) The spillover effects of infill developments on local housing prices, Journal of Regional Science and Urban Economics,Vol. 43,pp. 850-861.
  37. Parsi, Pourhassan; Sajjadi, Jila; Technical, Venus; Sarrafi, Mozafar (2015) Planning for infill development in urban spaces (Case study: Bojnourd), Journal of Geography and Regional Development, Spring and Summer, Volume 13, Number 1 (24 consecutive), pp. 90-71.
  38. Poorahmad, Ahmad; Habibi, Kiomars; Keshavarz, Mahnaz (2010) The evolution of the concept of urban regeneration as a new approach in worn-out urban contexts, Islamic Iranian city studies, Autumn, Volume 1, Number 1, pp. 73- 92.
  39. Poorahmad, Ahmad; Zanganeh, Ahmad; Shahraki, Saeed; Arvin, Mahmoud (2015) Identification of physical tissue capacities for infill development using hybrid decision making models and GIS (Case study: Ahvaz city), Journal of Geography and Environmental Sustainability, Volume 5, Number 16, pp. 17-37.
  40. Puustinen, Tuulia & Pennanen, Kyosti & Falkenbach,Heidi &Viitanen Kauko (2018), The distribution of perceived advantages and disadvantages of infill development among owners of a commonhold and its’ implications,Journal of Land Use Policy,Vol. 75,pp. 303-313.
  41. Qurbani, Rasool; Poor Mohammadi, Mohammad Reza (2003) Dimensions and Strategies of the Compactness Paradigm of Urban Spaces, Modares Journal of Humanities, Summer, Volume 7, Number 2 (29), pp.108-85.
  42. Rafieian, Mojtaba; Barati, Nasser; Aram, Marzieh (2010) Measuring the capacity of development of unused spaces in the center of Qazvin city with emphasis on the approach of infill development, Quarterly Journal of Architecture and Urban Planning, Autumn and Winter, Volume 3, Number 5, pp.45-61.
  43. Rahimi, Akbar (1397) Intermediate urban development, a new approach to urban land conservation in Tabriz, Journal of Geography and Planning, No. 63, 22 consecutive, pp. 77-98.
  44. Rahnama, Mohammad Rahim; Abbaszadeh, Gholamreza (2008) Principles and principles of measuring the physical form of the city, first edition, Mashhad, Mashhad University Jihad Publications.
  45. Razavian, Mohammadtaghi & Samadi, Roghayeh (2016)  Evaluation of Infill Development Potential in Zone 8 of Tabriz by Analysis Network Process Method, Journal of Scientific Research,June, Vol.4, No.2. (In Persian).
  46. Roberts, Peter(2000)The evolution, definition and purpose of urban regeneration,Publisher Urban Regeneration.
  47. Sadr Mousavi, Mirstar; Rahimi, Akbar (2012) An Analysis of the Physical Development of Tabriz and the Destruction of Agricultural Lands and Urban Green Spaces, Journal of Geography and Urban-Regional Planning, Autumn, Volume, No. 32, pp. 299-310.
  48. Saeidi Rezvani N & Kazemi,Navid(2011) Recognition of Infill development in proportion to the critique of current housing development policies (mehr housing scheme)Case study Natanz city,Journal of Human Geography Research Quarterly, Vol.43, Issue.75,pp. 113-132.
  49. Saif al-Dini, Frank; Poorahmad, Ahmad; Ziari, the dignity of God; Nader Dehghani Alvar, Seyed Ali (2013) Investigation of the contexts and obstacles of smart city growth in middle cities Case study: Khorramabad city, Journal of Land Management, Autumn and Winter, Volume 5, Number 2, pp. 260-241.
  50. Saremi, Hamidreza, (2013), A Study of Development from within Boroujerd, Journal of Urban and Rural Management, Journal of Urban Management, Autumn and Winter, Volume-, Number 32, pp.310-299.
  51. Shafaati, Arezoo (2010) infill Development, Towards an Optimal Urban Development Strategy (Case Study: Historical-Cultural Axis of Tabriz Metropolis), Master Thesis, Supervised by Mohammad Reza Pourmohammadi, Faculty of Planning and Environmental Sciences, University of Tabriz.
  52. Sheikhi, Hojjat; Zakir Haghighi, Kianoosh; Mansouri, Sahar (2013) Scattered study on the city of Boroujerd and its infill development strategies, Journal of Research and Planning, Winter, Fourth Year, Volume 4, Number 15, pp.37-56.
  53. Soleimani, Mohammad; Zanganeh, Ahmad; Ahmadi, Mazhar (2014) Worn textures have a capacity for internal development of cities (study sample: Saqez city), the first national conference on worn and historical urban textures, May 9 and 10, Kashan University.
  54. Steiner,Frederick,R & Butler,Kent. (2006) Planning and Urban Design Standards, Publisher American Planning Association (APA).
  55. Toppeta, D. (2010). The Smart City Vision: How Innovation and ICT Can Build Smart, “Livable”, Sustainable Cities.
  56. Walters, David &Brown, Linda(2004) Design First: Design based planning for communities, Pablisher Architectural Press.
  57. Ziari, the dignity of God; Poorahmad, Ahmad; Poor Rozgar, Hamzeh (2015) Identifying and Examining the Existing Potentials and Capabilities of Land with a Key to infill Development (Case Study: Sardasht Neighborhoods), Journal of Urban Management Studies, Winter, Volume 7, Number 24, pp. 98-79.